-
Quality of Life in the Military
Returning Veterans Need Help
The White House has not adequately reciprocated service members’ commitment; data shows danger in finances, health, mental stability, and family life.
Full Version: Quality of Life in the Military
-
Military Families Are Fed Up
Public Opinion by Ruy Teixeira
Polls show that veterans and their families are sick and tired of the Bush administration’s remarkably poor job of helping them out.
HONORING, NOT PITYING, OUR TROOPS
Dr. Leonard Wong
Strategic Studies Institute
How many of our troops lost a leg, arm, foot, or hand as a result of the war in Iraq?
a ) Less than 300
b ) 1,298
c ) 3,423
d ) More than 5,000
Our perceptions of the military and the current war in Iraq largely are shaped by what we see and hear in the media. On the topic of amputees resulting from Operation IRAQI FREEDOM, a quick Lexis-Nexis search reveals hundreds of media stories in the past 2 years. We’ve all seen segments on television, read stories in newspapers or magazines, or listened to pieces on the radio about Soldier or Marine amputees getting state-of-the-art prostheses, troops courageously learning how to adjust to their injuries, and even how some soldiers are skiing or running races despite their wounds.
Getting back to the question, though—the correct answer is that there have been less than 300 amputations. Surprised? If you chose a higher number, you are in good company. This same question was posed to over 50 of this year’s incoming class of U.S. Army War College students—many of whom wear Iraq combat patches on their uniforms. Only a half-dozen picked the correct answer.
Why would so many people, including those in the military profession, be so far off the mark? We could blame the news media for hyping the stories. But politicians, celebrities, and even those in uniform have been drawn to (and promulgated) these stories. Or we could point to the waning popularity of the war as creating a greater focus on casualties. But that would not explain why both hawks and doves tend to misjudge the extent of amputations. Perhaps the reason the number of Operation IRAQI FREEDOM amputees is overestimated is because the perceived magnitude is influenced by two very different perspectives of these wounded warriors.
The first perspective is one of admiration and gratitude for the sacrifice that these soldiers made for their nation. While the circumstances are heartbreaking, there is something reassuring about the perseverance and grittiness of the American soldier. This point of view appreciates the willingness of the military profession to put themselves into perilous conditions on someone else’s behalf. This perspective—admiring the tenacity of our troops—however, co-exists with another view.
The second and perhaps more common perspective, cloaks itself in admiration, but is really one of pity. This point of view bypasses notions of duty and service and instead dwells on misfortune and unfairness. With this perspective, soldiers are perceived not as professionals serving their nation, but as hapless victims. With our society increasingly viewing sacrifice and service as niceties but also as something somebody else should do, magnifying the potential cost of being a soldier helps to justify that belief.
For those in the military profession, the danger lies in inadvertently fostering this second perspective, while also holding the first. There is a precarious inclination to assume that inordinate societal interest in amputees (or PTSD or divorce rates) stems from an appreciation for our soldiers’ sacrifices when it is actually motivated by an increasing tendency to view our soldiers as victims.
The adversity and hardships endured by our troops should never be overlooked, ignored, or discounted. The difference between honoring and pitying our soldiers for their sacrifices, however, is significant. Much of America is still struggling with the concept of the military as a profession. Our society continues to carry much of the baggage of a draft-era Army, and cannot fully comprehend that today’s soldiers are volunteering to join an institution that may put them into harm’s way. With fewer and fewer Americans today experiencing military service, it is not surprising that many parts of our society hold this misunderstanding.
A more troubling potential, however, is that those in uniform may also unintentionally begin viewing themselves as victims. With a heavy public focus on casualties during a protracted war, it would be easy for our troops to start perceiving themselves not as a professionals guided by notions of sacrifice or service, but as victims deserving compensation and entitlements. Considering the magnificent success of our all-volunteer professional Army, such a shift in attitude, however, would be a real pity.
Dr. Leonard Wong
Strategic Studies Institute
How many of our troops lost a leg, arm, foot, or hand as a result of the war in Iraq?
a ) Less than 300
b ) 1,298
c ) 3,423
d ) More than 5,000
Our perceptions of the military and the current war in Iraq largely are shaped by what we see and hear in the media. On the topic of amputees resulting from Operation IRAQI FREEDOM, a quick Lexis-Nexis search reveals hundreds of media stories in the past 2 years. We’ve all seen segments on television, read stories in newspapers or magazines, or listened to pieces on the radio about Soldier or Marine amputees getting state-of-the-art prostheses, troops courageously learning how to adjust to their injuries, and even how some soldiers are skiing or running races despite their wounds.
Getting back to the question, though—the correct answer is that there have been less than 300 amputations. Surprised? If you chose a higher number, you are in good company. This same question was posed to over 50 of this year’s incoming class of U.S. Army War College students—many of whom wear Iraq combat patches on their uniforms. Only a half-dozen picked the correct answer.
Why would so many people, including those in the military profession, be so far off the mark? We could blame the news media for hyping the stories. But politicians, celebrities, and even those in uniform have been drawn to (and promulgated) these stories. Or we could point to the waning popularity of the war as creating a greater focus on casualties. But that would not explain why both hawks and doves tend to misjudge the extent of amputations. Perhaps the reason the number of Operation IRAQI FREEDOM amputees is overestimated is because the perceived magnitude is influenced by two very different perspectives of these wounded warriors.
The first perspective is one of admiration and gratitude for the sacrifice that these soldiers made for their nation. While the circumstances are heartbreaking, there is something reassuring about the perseverance and grittiness of the American soldier. This point of view appreciates the willingness of the military profession to put themselves into perilous conditions on someone else’s behalf. This perspective—admiring the tenacity of our troops—however, co-exists with another view.
The second and perhaps more common perspective, cloaks itself in admiration, but is really one of pity. This point of view bypasses notions of duty and service and instead dwells on misfortune and unfairness. With this perspective, soldiers are perceived not as professionals serving their nation, but as hapless victims. With our society increasingly viewing sacrifice and service as niceties but also as something somebody else should do, magnifying the potential cost of being a soldier helps to justify that belief.
For those in the military profession, the danger lies in inadvertently fostering this second perspective, while also holding the first. There is a precarious inclination to assume that inordinate societal interest in amputees (or PTSD or divorce rates) stems from an appreciation for our soldiers’ sacrifices when it is actually motivated by an increasing tendency to view our soldiers as victims.
The adversity and hardships endured by our troops should never be overlooked, ignored, or discounted. The difference between honoring and pitying our soldiers for their sacrifices, however, is significant. Much of America is still struggling with the concept of the military as a profession. Our society continues to carry much of the baggage of a draft-era Army, and cannot fully comprehend that today’s soldiers are volunteering to join an institution that may put them into harm’s way. With fewer and fewer Americans today experiencing military service, it is not surprising that many parts of our society hold this misunderstanding.
A more troubling potential, however, is that those in uniform may also unintentionally begin viewing themselves as victims. With a heavy public focus on casualties during a protracted war, it would be easy for our troops to start perceiving themselves not as a professionals guided by notions of sacrifice or service, but as victims deserving compensation and entitlements. Considering the magnificent success of our all-volunteer professional Army, such a shift in attitude, however, would be a real pity.
QUOTE(Marine @ Jan 2 2008, 10:11 PM) 
HONORING, NOT PITYING, OUR TROOPS
Dr. Leonard Wong
Strategic Studies Institute
How many of our troops lost a leg, arm, foot, or hand as a result of the war in Iraq?
a ) Less than 300
b ) 1,298
c ) 3,423
d ) More than 5,000
Our perceptions of the military and the current war in Iraq largely are shaped by what we see and hear in the media. On the topic of amputees resulting from Operation IRAQI FREEDOM, a quick Lexis-Nexis search reveals hundreds of media stories in the past 2 years. We’ve all seen segments on television, read stories in newspapers or magazines, or listened to pieces on the radio about Soldier or Marine amputees getting state-of-the-art prostheses, troops courageously learning how to adjust to their injuries, and even how some soldiers are skiing or running races despite their wounds.
Getting back to the question, though—the correct answer is that there have been less than 300 amputations. Surprised? If you chose a higher number, you are in good company.
Dr. Leonard Wong
Strategic Studies Institute
How many of our troops lost a leg, arm, foot, or hand as a result of the war in Iraq?
a ) Less than 300
b ) 1,298
c ) 3,423
d ) More than 5,000
Our perceptions of the military and the current war in Iraq largely are shaped by what we see and hear in the media. On the topic of amputees resulting from Operation IRAQI FREEDOM, a quick Lexis-Nexis search reveals hundreds of media stories in the past 2 years. We’ve all seen segments on television, read stories in newspapers or magazines, or listened to pieces on the radio about Soldier or Marine amputees getting state-of-the-art prostheses, troops courageously learning how to adjust to their injuries, and even how some soldiers are skiing or running races despite their wounds.
Getting back to the question, though—the correct answer is that there have been less than 300 amputations. Surprised? If you chose a higher number, you are in good company.
Really? Not according to this info. Through Jan 2007 (that's almost one year ago), 749 amputations from OIF have been reported.
"A census conducted by the Department of Defense (DoD) indicates 749 amputations from OIF and 42 amputations from OEF through January 2007. The amputation rate is 3.3 percent among all wounded troops.
The House Committee on Veterans' Affairs.
http://veterans.house.gov/hearings/Testimony.aspx?TID=7260
QUOTE(amy @ Jan 3 2008, 07:31 AM)
Really? Not according to this info. Through Jan 2007 (that's almost one year ago), 749 amputations from OIF have been reported.
"A census conducted by the Department of Defense (DoD) indicates 749 amputations from OIF and 42 amputations from OEF through January 2007. The amputation rate is 3.3 percent among all wounded troops.
The House Committee on Veterans' Affairs.
http://veterans.house.gov/hearings/Testimony.aspx?TID=7260
"A census conducted by the Department of Defense (DoD) indicates 749 amputations from OIF and 42 amputations from OEF through January 2007. The amputation rate is 3.3 percent among all wounded troops.
The House Committee on Veterans' Affairs.
http://veterans.house.gov/hearings/Testimony.aspx?TID=7260
If you'd read the article you'd realize the article was written in 2005.
QUOTE
On the topic of amputees resulting from Operation IRAQI FREEDOM, a quick Lexis-Nexis search reveals hundreds of media stories in the past 2 years.
It still doesn't alter the fact that for each amputee there are many stories about each and if I hadn't posted this story it would be easy to assume many more than the 749 you site.
By the way, the military is preparing for the cut backs anticipated from the democrats.
A MSgt I know in the Air Force sent me these in an email.
A MSgt I know in the Air Force sent me these in an email.
QUOTE(Marine @ Jan 3 2008, 01:28 PM)
If you'd read the article you'd realize the article was written in 2005.
It still doesn't alter the fact that for each amputee there are many stories about each and if I hadn't posted this story it would be easy to assume many more than the 749 you site.
It still doesn't alter the fact that for each amputee there are many stories about each and if I hadn't posted this story it would be easy to assume many more than the 749 you site.
I guess the point of the article you posted is that we should not "pity" soldier amputees... in fact, we shouldn't pity any seriously injured soldier. Rather we should honor them for their service. Okay. I can do that, as long as the soldiers are "volunteers".
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.